Skip to main content

The 3 Octaves

A maturity model for software engineering — grounded in timeless principles and amplified by AI acceleration.

Octave 1 — Signal Definition (Thinking Before Building)

Octave 1 governs intent.
It is about understanding problems clearly enough that automation becomes safe.

  1. Understanding Is the First Deliverable

    Code is not the start of work.
    Clarity is.

    If a problem cannot be explained without jargon, diagrams, or hand-waving, it is not ready to be built — by humans or AI.

  2. Problem Framing Determines the Outcome

    Most failures come from solving the wrong problem well.

    We invest more effort in framing than in solutions, because a correctly framed problem often approaches its own solution.

  3. Requirements Are Engineering Artifacts

    Requirements are not paperwork, tickets, or formalities.

    They are compressed engineering decisions — and they must be precise enough that someone else (human or AI) can act on them correctly.

  4. Constraints Are Part of the Solution

    Constraints are not obstacles to creativity.
    They are what make solutions real.

    Time, cost, performance, security, scale, and operability are defined early — not “handled later.”

  5. Assumptions Must Be Made Explicit

    Unstated assumptions are hidden bugs.

    Every critical assumption — technical or business — is surfaced, written down, and challenged before work proceeds.

  6. AI Is Used Only After Intent Is Clear

    AI accelerates execution, not understanding.

    We do not ask AI to “figure it out.”
    We ask AI to help implement what has already been thought through.

  7. Decisions Leave a Trail

    Important decisions are recorded while the context is fresh.

    Architecture Decision Records (or equivalents) exist so the future does not have to guess the past.

  8. Speed Is a Choice, Not a Default

    Moving fast is valuable only after direction is fixed.

    We slow down deliberately while thinking — so execution can move without hesitation.

Octave 2 — Signal Construction (Building With Discipline)

Octave 2 governs execution.
This is where AI accelerates output — and where engineering rigor must keep pace.

  1. Architecture Comes Before Implementation

    Code is a consequence, not a starting point.

    We establish system boundaries, data flows, failure modes, and interfaces before AI generates code.

  2. AI Output Is Treated Like Junior Code

    AI-generated code is not special.

    It is reviewed, tested, refactored, or rejected — exactly as if it came from a new team member.

  3. Tests Express Intent, Not Just Coverage

    Tests are not written to satisfy tools.

    They exist to explain:

    • what the system is supposed to do
    • what it must never do
    • what it guarantees under stress
  4. Verification Is Continuous, Not a Phase

    Verification does not happen “after development.”

    It is embedded into:

    • design
    • implementation
    • code review
    • deployment
  5. Small Systems Beat Clever Systems

    We prefer simple, understandable designs over impressive ones.

    If a system requires constant explanation, it is already failing.

  6. Tooling Must Reduce Cognitive Load

    Tools exist to simplify thinking — not replace it.

    Any tool (AI or otherwise) that increases confusion is treated as technical debt.

  7. Automation Follows Understanding

    We automate what we understand deeply.

    Automation without comprehension creates speed without safety.

  8. Change Is Designed, Not Accidentally Introduced

    Every change has a blast radius.

    We design changes so that:

    • failures are contained
    • rollbacks are possible
    • recovery is predictable

Octave 3 — Signal Propagation (Operating, Owning, Sustaining)

Octave 3 governs reality.
This is where software proves whether it was engineered — or merely assembled.

  1. Production Is the Only Source of Truth

    Designs, tests, and staging environments are hypotheses.

    Production behavior is fact — and it always has the final word.

  2. Every System Must Be Observable

    If a system cannot explain itself, it cannot be trusted.

    Logs, metrics, traces, and alerts are not optional — they are part of the system’s interface.

  3. Ownership Does Not End at Deployment

    Shipping is a milestone, not a finish line.

    Engineers remain accountable for:

    • reliability
    • performance
    • security
    • operability
  4. Failures Must Leave the System Better

    Incidents are tuition, not embarrassment.

    Every failure produces:

    • clearer understanding
    • safer defaults
    • stronger safeguards
  5. Systems Must Outlive Their Creators

    Good systems survive:

    • people leaving
    • tools changing
    • assumptions expiring

    If a system only works because its author is present, it is unfinished.

  6. Operational Simplicity Is a Feature

    The easiest system to operate usually wins.

    Complex operations are a tax paid every day — not just during outages.

  7. Security Is a Design Constraint, Not a Patch

    Security added later is security already compromised.

    Threat modeling, access control, and data protection are considered from the start — and revisited continuously.

  8. Learning Must Flow Backward

    Operations inform design.

    Production feedback reshapes:

    • requirements
    • architecture
    • automation
    • tooling

    Without this loop, teams repeat the same failures faster.

Why 3 Octaves?

  1. Octave means eight — in computing, 8 bits = 1 byte, a complete, meaningful unit formed from simple parts (28 states).
  2. In mathematics and music, an octave repeats the same structure at a higher resolution and capability, not a different one.
  3. A symphony emerges from simple patterns, repeated, layered across octaves, and shaped into coherence.
  4. 3 Octaves applies this idea to engineering: the same principles, applied with increasing scope, responsibility, and consequence.
  5. Octave 1 defines the signal — understanding problems clearly before acting.
  6. Octave 2 constructs the signal into systems, where discipline and verification matter most.
  7. Octave 3 propagates the signal into production, where systems meet time, scale, and reality.
  8. The Three Octaves follow a simple progression: clarity → construction → consequence, repeated with increasing power (O1 → O2 → O3).